• Adam Smith Institute

    Adam Smith Institute place holder
  • Philosophy & Logic

    Philosophy and Logic
  • Cambridge

  • Children’s SF

    Children's Science Fiction
  • Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 422 other subscribers

Tweaking the government proposal to make supermarkets charge 5p for each plastic bag

eco-bagThe UK government proposes to make supermarkets in England charge 5p for plastic bags from 2015 onwards.  Northern Ireland and Wales already impose charges for bags, and Scotland intends to do so from next year.  Several countries outside the UK, notably France, already do this.  The proposal is that the money so raised will not go to the stores themselves or to the government, but to “environmental charities.”  The problem has been that over 8 billion bags are used annually in the UK.  They can take 1,000 years to decay, and present a danger to wildlife on land and at sea as well as being a blight on the natural beauty of the countryside.

Two modest tweaks would improve this proposal and increase its acceptability and popularity.  To charge shoppers an extra 5p per bag at a time when many families are struggling to make ends meet is bad timing.  An exemption should be made for biodegradable bags.  I was surprised some time back to see that what seemed like a clear plastic sheet covering my sandwich was described as degradable, and was apparently derived from corn.  Several biodegradable clear food wraps are already on the market, and I doubt it would take much to develop a shopping bag designed to degrade within a set time.  We could even put up a worthwhile prize for the inventor who manages to produce one cheaply enough.  Supermarkets might wish to offer the option of free biodegradable bags as alternatives to 5p plastic ones.

My second tweak is that “environmental charities” which undertake political campaigns should be excluded from those receiving the proceeds of the 5p charge.  It might go instead to those that do practical work to protect wildlife and habitat, that clean up rivers, etc.  It should not go to those that campaign against business and lobby for new and higher taxes, or for those that seek to limit our behaviour to what they deem acceptable.  Given those two tweaks, I think the proposed 5p charge will attract fewer grumbles that it will without them.


4 Responses

  1. I have a bag full of carrier bags in my hotel kitchen, the bottom ones are already starting to fall to bits, and they have been in there only for nine months.
    They are almost all “Tesco” bags, which are marked as biodegradable, not quite as strong as their old plastic ones, but they certainly do degrade a lot quicker than I expected. Other brands of bags in there do last a lot longer, and do get reused more often because of their strength and lack of ventilation holes.

    Removing “political” charities from the possible beneficiaries certainly seems like an excellent idea, now if only we could do that with all government funding. Payments from the government to “charities” that lobby government has always seemed to be strange to me, if not a bit incestuous.

  2. Brilliant! And I believe that the Germans already have invented biodegradable carrier bags.

  3. Biodegradable plastic is not new. Nearly 30 years ago plastic ‘ mono cups ‘ which are used in vending machines became available in biodegradable plastic. I saw cups which had been thrown/blown into bushes which disintegrated into dust if lightly touched. It took a few months of weathering for this to happen but the end result was the disappearing mono cups complete with their dust and whatever environmental effect it would have. Incidentally, those bushes are still flourishing and they look extremely healthy.

  4. The problem with all taxes and levies is that once started they never end. How long have the Napoleonic Wars been over? Why are we still paying for it? Does anyone believe that they won’t increase the amount of the levy? Or the scope? Or change who gets the money?

    I don’t care what they call it or what camouflage they dress it up in, “No New Taxes.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: